for me it's not even an anti-monarchy thing (although I am) the sort of awards/recognition in any sphere or society I'm suspicious of Whether it's the Brit Awards for music, the Oscars/Baftas for film, or OBE/MBEs in British society - I just don't understand what they are for. I don't get the rules for selection and I don't get the rules for deciding on a winner. I know what they are SUPPOSED to be, but I'm suspicious of them all. ( how long before Scorcese got an Oscar for example) If I make an album, write a book, direct a film, or invent something - that's my choice and my reward comes from the upshot of that - be it sales, kudos, patent or whatever. Absolutely these awards will give an uplift to anyone selected - but why THEM and not anyone else working in that field It seems to be more about validating the awarder, not the awardee (if those are real words)