Well, if he's going he's going and he may well have won the League Cup albeit on penalties against lowly Cardiff City but the stats don't lie. Defeat at Swansea meant Liverpool recorded their lowest total of top-flight league victories (14) and lowest points tally (52) since 1953-54. They also scored the fewest league goals (47) for 20 years and an eighth-placed finish was their worst for 18 years. His reaction and behaviour during the whole sorry saga of the Suarez affair was a complete PR disaster to the reputation of the club.