Panther, your very point was raised by the poster in question on the first page (in a less confusing manner as I don't think she got herself in a muddle like you did). And as to "Would you feel comfortable asking this question?" If it was made in an effort to enhance understanding of the issues in play (as I believe it was)- then why not? Of course, if you understand the question to be demanding justification, or aggressive in its intent, then I could see your point. But I think the poser of the question has demonstrated that s/he never meant that to be the case, despite some (at most) tactless phrasing.